My Traffic Stop

I was on my way to a 6:00 p.m. meeting and came flying down the hill on to our city’s lake drive like I had done 10,000 times. I was thinking about the day, bright and sunny, and the water, riled a little by the wind. I love Lake Michigan in all its glory and it’s a daily thing – whenever I see it I revel in it. What a beautiful place. And so I came flying down that hill in my old 2005 Thunderbird just enjoying being alive.

And then I saw the lights flashing behind me.

Officer: Do you know how fast you were going, young lady? (I am 70. A decent-looking 70 but still 70.)

Me: Well, probably over 40 (guessing because I had no idea, I was looking at the lake after all and not my speedometer).

Officer: 49. 19 miles over the speed limit.

Me: Oh.

Officer: Great looking car. How much is a car like this worth?

Me: Not much. About $10,000. It’s pretty but not that valuable. Except to me.

Officer: Just $10,000, really? You’d think it’d be worth a lot more than that. Beautiful car. Really. So, hey, we’re doing this enhanced enforcement thing right now because the neighbors (gesturing up the hill) have been complaining about all the speeders. So I’m really sorry but we’re doing this special enforcement thing.

Me: I understand.

Officer: I’m really sorry, ma’am. Yeah, it’s just that the neighbors keep complaining so the department had to respond. You know? (Now I am starting to feel sorry for him.)

Me: That’s okay. (He asks for my license and I hand it to him. He goes to his car and comes back about five minutes later.)

Officer: Okay, well, here’s the citation. Now you can go down to the courthouse and contest it. Just let them know you want to fight it. It’s not hard. All the directions are right here. (He holds the ticket and points with his pen how I can appeal the ticket.) I’m really sorry about this. It’s just this enhanced enforcement thing.

Me: I know. You’re just doing your job.

I looked at the $204 price tag on my little reverie flying down the hill looking at Lake Michigan and drove slowly on to my meeting. He followed me for a while and then made a U-turn to go back to his hiding place at the bottom of the hill. And that was it. All done.


That’s Jan’s traffic stop. White woman, white officer. Sunny afternoon, beautiful lake, no problem. This is my experience. This is what I expect, except for this officer being uncommonly apologetic for enforcing the law. I never for a moment worried that anything bad would happen as a result of this encounter (aside from the fine). But it never hit me until weeks later what a textbook example of white privilege this traffic stop had been. If the concept had been an abstraction before, it wasn’t any longer.

I get it now.

6 Comments on “My Traffic Stop

  1. Great post, Jan. I have a feeling that our blindness to white woman privilege is the same what as what some men experience when they don’t get that being free from sexual harassment is a male privilege thing so they don’t understand that we see it through a different lens and it is truly frightening for us. Just kinda thinking out loud and always hoping to find a way to make those who are privileged (read me and my male friends) understand how it feels to not enjoy that privilege.


  2. The last time I was stopped it was for speeding. I was running late for a brand new job in s new town and didn’t see the speed limit change from 55 to 45. The young officer asked me why I was in such a hurry and I told him. He stepped away for a couple of seconds, came back and said something about it being my lucky day. Their printer wasn’t working. I thanked him and promised to slow down. I drove s couple of miles before I thought, “their printer wasn’t working? B.S.” White lady. White officer. No ticket.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: